Blog

Category: Philosophy

Property Rights

9 December 2008

Dear friend Sharlee McNamee loves her property on the Corona del Mar beach and she certainly knows how to make the most of it. While I worked in Orange County years ago, driving down from L.A., Sharlee let me stay there on weekends. She and her husband, George, hosted a wonderful celebration for me, as well as countless fund-raisers for films and causes; she was southern California’s supreme beach hostess during the Eighties, welcoming new intellectuals into her warm, inviting world for hours of debate and discussion about Ayn Rand’s philosophy.

For the past seven years, she’s been putting that philosophy into personal practice by defending her beloved property against an assault by the state of California, a noble effort which is finally getting aid from the Pacific Legal Foundation. Win or lose—and justice means 100 percent victory over California’s dictatorial Coastal Commission, a monstrosity that should be abolished—Sharlee McNamee should be supported by anyone who favors individual rights.

Peikoff, Pop and Screen Shots

8 December 2008

Soul

Do dogs have some degree of freedom of the will? Dr. Leonard Peikoff, experimenting with a roundtable format, addresses this question and another in answer to an excellent letter from a truck driver—whom I think has a good point—about whether Objectivists tend to denigrate and dismiss middle class values and those who hold them. I don’t like this new format as a replacement of the usual podcast—I prefer Dr. Peikoff’s solo work as a rule—and I don’t think the participants get to the core of this correspondent’s concerns. Listen to the podcast and judge for yourself.

Shine Through It

Sorry to say that pop singer Seal’s new album, Soul, is a bust. His relaxed vocal style does not suit these original rhythm and blues tunes, which require more intensity than Seal can muster. Seal, it turns out, lacks soul. But Seal managed to inspire actor Terrence Howard to write a song for his new album, Shine Through It. The soulful tune is called “Sanctuary,” and, while the album is mixed, Howard’s an honest artist whose sincerity comes through on every track. He wrote the tender, lush and romantic “Sanctuary” after hearing Seal and his wife, model Heidi Klum, talk about how they met and fell in love.

4 Months, 3 Weeks and 2 Days

After hearing it compared to the brilliant German picture, The Lives of Others, I finally got around to seeing the Romanian picture 4 Months, 3 Weeks and 2 Days (2007). The movie concerns two young college students in communist Romania in 1987; it is completely non-intellectual and, therefore, not comparable to The Lives of Others, an excellent dramatization of life under dictatorship. 4 Months, 3 Weeks and 2 Days is a crude, naturalistic picture about young woman’s illegal abortion that manages to avoid any of the relevant issues surrounding her unwanted pregnancy, such as Catholicism, communism and the motives of the woman who helps her (how she wound up pregnant and by whom is not addressed). One can only suppose about various motives in this stark, subtitled movie, and one inevitably does fill in the blanks, but ultimately this is a graphic slice of life about getting an abortion.

Pics, Passages and Pre-Presidential Obama

2 December 2008

The Obama presidency is shaping up and, as the saying goes, are we ever in for it. The pretense of Barack Obama’s credibility—especially honesty—is gone. During the campaign, Obama practically (and rightly) denounced Sen. Hillary Clinton as a liar when she falsely—and repeatedly—claimed she was under fire in Kosovo. He pointed out that she routinely substituted being First Lady for foreign policy experience—and now he has designated the woman who all but declared him unfit for the presidency as his secretary of state. You want change? His appointments are Clinton/Bush retreads, unmasking his change theme as a fraud less than a month after he was elected.

His campaign was predicated on pulling troops out of Iraq—a disastrous military deployment by Bush—only to reverse himself and name Bush’s Defense Secretary as his own and back off pulling troops out of Iraq. Clearly, President-elect Obama offers more of the same of what Leonard Peikoff dubbed “Clinbush” on the airwaves. But Obama’s having some relatively positive impact: suddenly, silent Bush head-nodders are denouncing socialism—never mind that Bush and Republicans were shoving it down our throats for the last eight years—after not lifting a finger to oppose Bush’s bailouts, Medicare drug subsidies and aid to Africa.

And the nation—in overwhelming opposition to our government—appears united in the people’s shared contempt for a bailout of failed corporations that make cars that not enough people want to buy to keep them in business—while they’re shackled by regulations that force them to pay outrageous wages and benefits to workers who make cars that nobody wants to buy. The tide is turning against socialism; we shall see how (actually, whether) the people respond (actually, whether they resist) when Obama/Pelosi/Reid/McCain/Clinton invoke total National Socialism. Even NPR liberals and their conservative, eco-religious brethren may not cotton to mandatory solar panels on the roof, nationalized banks and car companies and the Eco-Police coming to take their kids to mandatory Peace Corps camp in the Rain Forest.

On the upside, Obama has signaled that he may lift the ban on embryonic stem cell research, defend the right to an abortion via judicial appointments, pursue nuclear power development and attack Moslem Pakistan—none of which would happen under a Judeo-Christian administration. Also, Republicans, for the first time since Arizona Sen. Barry Goldwater’s historic defeat in the 1964 presidential election, are questioning their philosophy instead of making excuses for religious welfare-statism.

But there is an intriguing difference between the first Obama press rollout of cabinet appointments and his latest Hillary-fest; the designees were standing together around Obama in the photo frame at the first event—not so in the second, where Obama stood alone and tried to charm everyone with the sort of cheap, hammy mugging that liberals used to tag on Ronald Reagan, a model by Obama’s admission.

It’s all about Obama, all the time, which is not arrogance as much as superficiality and an ominous sign of what the man feels he needs in order to govern: adulation. An astonishingly honest appraisal of the incoming administration came from a Democratic congressman appearing recently on MSNBC—his name escapes me—in which he praised Obama, twice, for an ability to “make the trains run on time.” Either this moron does not know that this infamous phrase is widely associated with dictatorship—originally, I believe, from a comment by Italian fascist and Nazi ally Benito Mussolini; later associated with Nazi Germany—or, more ominously, he knows exactly the source.

On a sad note, Maryland businessman, real estate developer and Korean War veteran Leon Trager died at the age of 80. Mr. Trager was not a friend, but in my few encounters with him over 15 years as a journalist, he was selfish, generous and principled (thanks for the link, Jack).

John Lewis, Ph.D.

Good news comes from John Lewis, Ph.D., who, at the invitation of a member of Israel’s Knesset, is scheduled to address a conference this month in Israel, Facing Jihad, described as “a summit of European lawmakers who are united in their shared belief that Islam today poses a serious threat to Western civilization.” Professor Lewis is among my favorite teachers; he is writing, teaching a business course at Duke University, and he’s slated to teach a course at the upcoming Objectivist Conference 2009 in Boston. Dr. Lewis tells me that his lecture, “The Defeat of Islamic Totalitarianism: A Proper Policy,” is intended to urge lawmakers to make policy on a proper identification of the West’s enemy.

The Facing Jihad conference also features a screening of the Dutch short film, Fitna, and an address by its creator. I wrote about the outrageous Network Solutions ban on Fitna earlier this year [http://www.boxofficemojo.com/features/?id=2471&p=s.htm (scroll down and read “World Wide Web”)] so it’s good to see the filmmaker get an audience.

I can’t truly say the same about a number of recent motion pictures—and I know I’m behind on reviews—though I promise I’m on the lookout for quality movies and I’m excited about seeing some upcoming movies, such as Milk and Frost/Nixon.

Yes Man was better in concept than in practice—more exactly, the idea of a comedy about a man who says ‘yes’ to everything was not properly executed—and both Body of Lies (with DiCaprio and Crowe) and Pride and Glory were disappointing in spite of Russell Crowe and Edward Norton, respectively, two of Tinseltown’s best actors. The scripts were terrible as usual and Leonardo DiCaprio was awful, unlike his performance in Blood Diamond.

Quantum of Solace and Changeling were excruciatingly dull but both benefitted from low expectations and were mildly interesting in spots. I admit I hate the new thuggish, brain-dead Bond—I hated Casino Royale, Sony’s first Bond re-hatch—but Judi Dench can read the McDonald’s menu and make it sound fascinating.

Lippy Angelina Jolie in Changeling, Clint Eastwood’s stylish Los Angeles crime saga, shows she can act, though any honest person can’t help but notice the glaring double-standard about the non-reaction to this picture—with boys being caged, molested and mutilated—and the outrage over the Dakota Fanning rape scene in the Christian-killed Hounddog. Hollywood apparently scotches anything the religionists object to if it involves sexual abuse and girls. But both Hollywood and the religionists share an extremely high tolerance for sexual and physical torture of boys.

Four Christmases

Not as atrocious as I figured it would be—and Reese Witherspoon can do no wrong—is Four Christmases, though Vince Vaughan still looks (and sounds) like he needs a few weeks of detoxification. The movie is moderately foul as these things go. Jon Voight, Sissy Spacek and Robert Duvall are wasted as usual. I do recommend the innocuous yet infectious High School Musical 3 and an interesting documentary called Dear Zachary which will break your heart, but more on those later. Best thing about Hollywood’s Christmas season so far: Mamma Mia! coming out on DVD.

Notes on National Socialism, Screen Shots

29 September 2008

As the nation continues its march toward national socialism, with President Bush and virtually everyone in Congress insisting financial collapse is imminent if their schemes aren’t immediately enacted—a total lie—writer Ed Cline provides an excellent commentary on the subject at the Rule of Reason blog. America is moving faster toward totalitarianism and, especially now, silence implies consent. Can a whole nation be held morally accountable for the actions of its government? Absolutely. Read The Ominous Parallels: The End of Freedom in America by Leonard Peikoff and see Stanley Kramer’s Judgment at Nuremberg and make up your own mind.

I did not have high hopes for Disney’s Beverly Hills Chihuahua, which I suspected would not be among the studio’s best doggie pictures (Disney’s Eight Below is the finest dog movie in recent years). Talking dogs and computer generated vermin dominate this piece of fluff, which manages to incorporate multiculturalism in the worst turn of events and is stolen by Andy Garcia voicing the only character—a German Shepherd named Delgado—to earn an emotional investment. Though not as insipid as The Game Plan, this is not Disney’s proudest work.

On the other hand, The Lucky Ones (currently in limited engagement), a comedy that makes you think about Americans being sacrificed in Iraq from the writer and director of the outstanding The Illusionist, is without question one of the year’s best pictures.

Objectivist Conference 2008

23 July 2008

OCON

Sorry about the delay in posting here. After an exciting several years at Box Office Mojo (BOM)—including our recent sponsorship of the Newport Beach Film Festival and my hosting Red River starring John Wayne—I have decided to move on. I wish the BOM bunch well in the future. This summer, I have been enjoying the Objectivist Conference (OCON) in Newport Beach, visiting Disneyland and the beaches of Malibu and working on other projects.

OCON 2008 was fabulous. The Ayn Rand Institute’s Yaron Brook and Onkar Ghate delivered a lecture series on cultural change, which was very rewarding. In a related development, the opening of the new Ayn Rand Center (ARC) in Washington, D.C. was also announced.

OCON highlights included two optional courses—a comprehensive three-lecture class by Clemson’s Eric Daniels on the history of free speech in America and Virginia Tech Professor Shoshana Milgram’s extremely informative four-lecture course on Ayn Rand’s admiration for It Can’t Happen Here by Sinclair Lewis. That’s one of my favorite novels and I gained new insights. During the class, I also learned about Ayn Rand’s appreciation for her lawyers and I enjoyed several such sidebars. Her note to Ann Watkins comes to mind.

Leonard Peikoff’s Question and Answer was a real treat—as others have observed, he’s in top form—and, while I was unable to attend every lecture, I enjoyed the general sessions. Archivist Jeff Britting showed me the impressive Ayn Rand Archives and the conference staff was thoroughly professional (thanks to Dave and Bryan). I missed having an opportunity to enroll in a course by Craig Biddle, whose Science of Selfishness class at Telluride last year was excellent, and finding the Independence Day luncheon was not easy (Arwen Morton’s patriotic vocal performances were outstanding) but, as usual, OCON was worth every dollar.